Clay vs Steel vs Non-Stick for Dal: Which Pot?

There is no best pot, only the right pot for the dish. Here is a plain comparison of clay, steel and non-stick for cooking dal, including the cases where clay is the wrong choice.

By Mudkraft ·

Side by side

Clay handiSteelNon-stick
HeatHeats slowly, holds heat long after the flame is offHeats fast, cools fast; thin steel can scorch at the baseHeats fast; coating limits how hot it should go
FlameLow to medium gas or wood; start coldAny heatLow to medium; avoid high heat
InductionNo, clay is not magneticUsually yes, if the base is magnetic steelOnly if the base is made for it
CareNo soap, season before first use, dry fullyEasiest: wash and goNo metal spoons; coating wears over time
BreakageCan crack if heated fast or droppedVery durableDurable, but the coating can scratch
Best forSlow dal, biryani, curries, dahiTadka, quick sabzi, everyday cookingEggs, low-oil quick cooking

When clay is the right pot

When it is not

A practical way to use both

Cook the dal slowly in clay, and make the tadka in a small steel pan. You get the slow simmer where it helps and the speed where it matters. If you are new to clay, season your handi first and choose the size using our buying guide.

Quick answers

Is dal cooked in a clay handi different?

Many people like the slow, even simmer clay gives, which suits dal that is cooked low for a long time. It is a matter of taste and method rather than a guaranteed difference.

Can I do the tadka in a clay handi?

You can, on a low flame once the pot is seasoned. Many cooks make the tadka in a small steel pan and pour it over, which is quicker and gentler on the clay.

Is clay cookware worth it if I only cook quickly?

Probably not for every day. Clay shines when you cook slowly. If most of your cooking is fast and hot, keep steel for that and use clay for the dishes that benefit from slow heat.

Ready to cook in clay?

Shop clay handi

Keep reading